The Old Commodore’s Compliments Sent Plump into Donelson!

Herman Melville (1819–1891) · 1866

iambic tetrameter · 145 lines · from Battle-Pieces and Aspects of the War

“Well, well, go on!” exclaimed the crowdTo him who thus much read aloud.“That’s all,” he said. “What! nothing more”“Enough for a cheer, though--hip, hurrah!”“But here’s old Baldy come again--”“More news!”--And now a different strain.

(Our own reporter a dispatch compiles,As best he may, from varied sources.)

Large re-enforcements have arrived--Munitions, men, and horses--For Grant, and all debarked, with stores.

The enemy’s field-works extend six miles--The gate still hid; so well contrived.

Yesterday stung us; frozen shoresSnow-clad, and through the drear defiles

And over the desolate ridges blewA Lapland wind.The main affairWas a good two hours’ steady fightBetween our gun-boats and the Fort.The Louisville’s wheel was smashed outright.A hundred-and-twenty-eight-pound ballCame planet-like through a starboard port,Killing three men, and wounding allThe rest of that gun’s crew,(The captain of the gun was cut in two);Then splintering and ripping went--Nothing could be its continent.In the narrow stream the Louisville,Unhelmed, grew lawless; swung around,And would have thumped and drifted, tillAll the fleet was driven aground,But for the timely order to retire.

Some damage from our fire, ’tis thought,Was done the water-batteries of the Fort.

Little else took place that day,Except the field artillery in lineWould now and then--for love, they say--Exchange a valentine.The old sharpshooting going on.Some plan afoot as yet unknown;So Friday closed round Donelson.

Great suffering through the night--A stinging one. Our heedless boysWere nipped like blossoms. Some dozenHapless wounded men were frozen.During day being struck down out of sight,And help-cries drowned in roaring noise,They were left just where the skirmish shifted--Left in dense underbrush now-drifted.Some, seeking to crawl in crippled plight,So stiffened--perished.Yet in spiteOf pangs for these, no heart is lost.Hungry, and clothing stiff with frost,Our men declare a nearing sunShall see the fall of Donelson.And this they say, yet not disownThe dark redoubts round Donelson,And ice-glazed corpses, each a stone--A sacrifice to Donelson;They swear it, and swerve not, gazing onA flag, deemed black, flying from Donelson.Some of the wounded in the woodWere cared for by the foe last night,Though he could do them little needed good,Himself being all in shivering plight.The rebel is wrong, but human yet;He’s got a heart, and thrusts a bayonet.He gives us battle with wondrous will--The blufff’s a perverted Bunker Hill.

The stillness stealing through the throngThe silent thought and dismal fear revealed;They turned and went,Musing on right and wrongAnd mysteries dimly sealed--Breasting the storm in daring discontent;The storm, whose black flag showed in heaven,As if to say no quarter there was givenTo wounded men in wood,Or true hearts yearning for the good--All fatherless seemed the human soul.But next day brought a bitterer bowl--On the bulletin-board this stood;

Saturday morning at 3 A.M.A stir within the Fort betrayedThat the rebels were getting under arms;Some plot these early birds had laid.But a lancing sleet cut him who staredInto the storm. After some vague alarms,Which left our lads unscared,Out sallied the enemy at dim of dawn,With cavalry and artillery, and wentIn fury at our environment.Under cover of shot and shellThree columns of infantry rolled on,Vomited out of Donelson--Rolled down the slopes like rivers of hell,Surged at our line, and swelled and pouredLike breaking surf. But unsubmergedOur men stood up, except where roaredThe enemy through one gap. We urgedOur all of manhood to the stress,But still showed shattered in our desperateness.Back set the tide,But soon afresh rolled in;And so it swayed from side to side--Far batteries joining in the din,Though sharing in another fray--Till all became an Indian fight,Intricate, dusky, stretching far away,Yet not without spontaneous planHowever tangled showed the plight;Duels all over ’tween man and man,Duels on cliff-side, and down in ravine,Duels at long range, and bone to bone;Duels every where flitting and half unseen.Only by courage good as their own,And strength outlasting theirs,Did our boys at last drive the rebels off.Yet they went not back to their distant lairsIn strong-hold, but loud in scoffMaintained themselves on conquered ground--Uplands; built works, or stalked around.Our right wing bore this onset. NoonBrought calm to Donelson.

The reader ceased; the storm beat hard;’Twas day, but the office-gas was lit;Nature retained her sulking-fit,In her hand the shard.Flitting faces took the hueOf that washed bulletin-board in view,And seemed to bear the public griefAs private, and uncertain of relief;Yea, many an earnest heart was won,As broodingly he plodded on,To find in himself some bitter thing,Some hardness in his lot as harrowingAs Donelson.

That night the board stood barren there,Oft eyes by wistful people passing,Who nothing saw but the rain-beads chasingEach other down the wafered square,As down some storm-beat grave-yard stone.But next day showed--

Words in this poem 35
aloud adv.
With a loud voice, or great noise; loudly; audibly. [Pref. a- + loud.]
hurrah interj.
A word used as a shout of joy, triumph, applause, encouragement, or welcome. [Cf. G., Dan., & Sw. hurra. Cf. Huzza.]
clad v.
To clothe. Holland.
drear n.
Sadness; dismalness.
outright adv.
Immediately; without delay; at once; as, he was killed outright.
went n.
Course; way; path; journey; direction.
continent a.
Serving to restrain or limit; restraining; opposing. [L. continens, -entis, prop., p. pr. of continere to hold together, to repress: cf. F. continent. See Contain.]
unhelmed a.
Etym: [Properly p. p. of unhelm.]
artillery n.
Munitions of war; implements for warfare, as slings, bows, and arrows. [OE. artilrie, OF. artillerie, arteillerie, fr. LL. artillaria, artilleria, machines and apparatus of all kinds used in war, vans laden with arms of any kind whi]
valentine n.
A sweetheart chosen on St. Valentine's Day.
sharpshooting n.
A shooting with great precision and effect; hence, a keen contest of wit or argument.
hapless a.
Without hap or luck; luckless; unfortunate; unlucky; unhappy; as, hapless youth; hapless maid.
underbrush n.
Shrubs, small trees, and the like, in a wood or forest, growing beneath large trees; undergrowth.
crawl v. i.
To move slowly by drawing the body along the ground, as a worm; to move slowly on hands and kness; to creep. [Dan. kravle, or Icel. krafla, to paw, scrabble with the hands; akin to Sw. kr to crawl; cf. LG. krabbeln, D. krabbelen to scratch.]
crippled a.
Lamed; lame; disabled; impeded.
plight v. t.
To weave; to braid; to fold; to plait. [OE. pliten; probably through Old French, fr. LL. plectare, L. plectere. See Plait, Ply.]
shall v. i.
To owe; to be under obligation for. [OE. shal, schal, imp. sholde, scholde, AS. scal, sceal, I am obliged, imp. scolde, sceolde, inf. sculan; akin to OS. skulan, pres. skal, imp. skolda, D. zullen,]
rebel a.
Pertaining to rebels or rebellion; acting in revolt; rebellious; as, rebel troops. [F. rebelle, fr. L. rebellis. See Rebel, v. t.]
wondrous adv.
In a wonderful or surprising manner or degree; wonderfully. [OE. wonders, adv. (later also adj.). See Wonder, n., and cf. -wards.]
bunker n.
A sort of chest or box, as in a window, the lid of which serves for a seat. Jamieson. [Scot. bunker, bunkart, a bench, or low chest, serving for a seat. Cf. Bunk, Bank, Bench.]
stillness n.
The quality or state of being still; quietness; silence; calmness; inactivity.
dismal a.
Fatal; ill-omened; unlucky. [Formerly a noun; e. g., "I trow it was in the dismalle." Chaucer. Of uncertain origin; but perh. (as suggested by Skeat) from OF. disme, F. dîme, tithe, the phr]
dimly adv.
In a dim or obscure manner; not brightly or clearly; with imperfect sight.
fatherless a.
Destitute of a living father; as, a fatherless child.
bulletin n.
A brief statement of facts respecting some passing event, as military operations or the health of some distinguished personage, issued by authority for the information of the public. [F. bulletin, fr. It. bullettino, dim. of bulletta, dim. of bulla, bolla, an edict of the pope, from L. bulla bubble. See Bull an edict.]
saturday n.
The seventh or last day of the week; the day following Friday and preceding Sunday. [OE. Saterday, AS. Sæterdæg, Sæterndæg, Sæternesdæg, literally, Saturn's day, fr. L. Saturnus Saturn + AS. dæg day; cf. L. dies Saturni.]
sleet n.
The part of a mortar extending from the chamber to the trunnions.
infantry n.
A body of children. B. Jonson. [F. infanterie, It. infanteria, fr. infante infant, child, boy servant, foot soldier, fr. L. infans, -antis, child; foot soldiers being formerly the servants and]
desperateness n.
Desperation; virulence.
afresh adv.
Anew; again; once more; newly. [Pref. a- + fresh.]
swayed a.
Bent down, and hollow in the back; sway-backed; -- said of a horse.
flitting n.
A flying with lightness and celerity; a fluttering.
unseen a.
Not seen or discovered.
shard n.
A plant; chard.
wistful a.
Longing; wishful; desirous. [For wishful; perhaps influenced by wistly, which is probably corrupted from OE. wisly certainly (from Icel. viss certain, akin to E. wit). See Wish.]

Definitions and etymologies from Webster's Unabridged Dictionary, 1913.

About this text

The Old Commodore’s Compliments Sent Plump into Donelson! is in the public domain. This text is taken from Battle-Pieces and Aspects of the War, Project Gutenberg ebook #12384; the transcription's header, footer and licence were removed and nothing else was changed. You may copy, print and reuse it freely.

Cite as: Herman Melville, The Old Commodore’s Compliments Sent Plump into Donelson!, in Battle-Pieces and Aspects of the War (1866), text of Project Gutenberg ebook #12384, Laurel, https://laurelpoetry.com/poem/melville-battle-pieces/the-old-commodore-s-compliments-sent-plump-into-donelson.html, id L00908.

Form and metre

The Old Commodore’s Compliments Sent Plump into Donelson! is 145 lines in 13 stanzas. The metre is iambic tetrameter, measured from the stress the words themselves fix (confidence 84%). 88% of its stressed syllables fall where the metre puts the beat. The lines average 8.1 syllables. 24 lines end on an unstressed syllable, a feminine ending. 25% of the lines run on without a stop at the line end.

See other poems in iambic tetrameter.

Measured by Laurel's pipeline, not copied from a handbook: how stress and metre are counted, how rhyme is lettered, how a drifted rhyme is found. Where the dictionary cannot confirm a rhyme the letter is withheld, not guessed.

Rhyme words, stanza by stanza

The word that ends each line, lettered by the rhyme it makes; a dash is a line whose rhyme the dictionary could not confirm.

  1. 1 AA--BB crowdA · aloudA · more · hurrah · againB · strainB
  2. 6 A--BCBDCDAAEEFGFG- blewA · wind · affair · fightB · fortC · outrightB · ballD · portC · allD · crewA · twoA · wentE · continentE · louisvilleF · aroundG · tillF · agroundG · retire
  3. 8 ABABCCB dayA · lineB · sayA · valentineB · onC · unknownC · donelsonB
  4. 9 AB--ABCCA-ADDEEFEFEEEGAGAHHII nightA · boysB · dozen · frozen · sightA · noiseB · shiftedC · driftedC · plightA · perished · spiteA · lostD · frostD · sunE · donelsonE · disownF · donelsonE · stoneF · donelsonE · onE · donelsonE · woodG · nightA · goodG · plightA · yetH · bayonetH · willI · hillI
  5. 10 ABCABC--DDEED throngA · revealedB · wentC · wrongA · sealedB · discontentC · heaven · given · woodD · goodD · soulE · bowlE · stoodD
  6. 11 -ABACBC-DDEFFEGHGHIIJKJKLMLNMNOPOPQRQRSSTT a.m · betrayedA · armsB · laidA · staredC · alarmsB · unscaredC · dawn · wentD · environmentD · shellE · onF · donelsonF · hellE · pouredG · unsubmergedH · roaredG · urgedH · stressI · desperatenessI · tideJ · inK · sideJ · dinK · frayL · fightM · awayL · planN · plightM · manN · ravineO · boneP · unseenO · ownP · theirsQ · offR · lairsQ · scoffR · groundS · aroundS · noonT · donelsonT
  7. 12 ABBACCDDEEFFE hardA · litB · fitB · shardA · hueC · viewC · griefD · reliefD · wonE · onE · thingF · harrowingF · donelsonE
  8. 13 A--A-- thereA · passing · chasing · squareA · stone · showed
Scansion, line by line

Each line with its syllable count and the stresses the words themselves fix: / stressed, ˘ unstressed, · a syllable the word leaves free and the metre decides. Read against iambic tetrameter. How this is done.

LineSyl.Stress
“Well, well, go on!” exclaimed the crowd8····˘/··
To him who thus much read aloud.8······˘/
“That’s all,” he said. “What! nothing more”8·····/˘·
“Enough for a cheer, though--hip, hurrah!”9˘/·····˘/
“But here’s old Baldy come again--”8······˘/
“More news!”--And now a different strain.8·····/˘·
(Our own reporter a dispatch compiles,10/·˘/˘·˘/˘/
As best he may, from varied sources.)9·····/˘/˘
Large re-enforcements have arrived--8··˘/˘·˘/
Munitions, men, and horses--7˘/˘··/˘
For Grant, and all debarked, with stores.8········
The enemy’s field-works extend six miles--9·/˘··˘/··
The gate still hid; so well contrived.8······˘/
Yesterday stung us; frozen shores8/˘˘··/˘·
Snow-clad, and through the drear defiles8········
And over the desolate ridges blew8···/˘/˘·
A Lapland wind.4·/··
The main affair4··˘/
Was a good two hours’ steady fight8·····/˘·
Between our gun-boats and the Fort.8··/·····
The Louisville’s wheel was smashed outright.9·/˘····//
A hundred-and-twenty-eight-pound ball9·/˘·/˘···
Came planet-like through a starboard port,9·/˘···/˘·
Killing three men, and wounding all8/˘···/˘·
The rest of that gun’s crew,6······
(The captain of the gun was cut in two);10·/˘·······
Then splintering and ripping went--8·/˘˘·/˘·
Nothing could be its continent.8/˘···/˘˘
In the narrow stream the Louisville,9··/˘··/˘·
Unhelmed, grew lawless; swung around,8˘/·/˘···
And would have thumped and drifted, till8·····/˘·
All the fleet was driven aground,8····/˘˘/
But for the timely order to retire.10···/˘/˘·˘/
Some damage from our fire, ’tis thought,8·/˘·//··
Was done the water-batteries of the Fort.10···/˘/˘···
Little else took place that day,7/˘·····
Except the field artillery in line9····˘/˘··
Would now and then--for love, they say--8········
Exchange a valentine.6˘/·/˘·
The old sharpshooting going on.7··/˘/˘·
Some plan afoot as yet unknown;8··˘/··˘/
So Friday closed round Donelson.8·/˘··/˘˘
Great suffering through the night--7·/˘˘···
A stinging one. Our heedless boys8·/˘·//˘·
Were nipped like blossoms. Some dozen8···/˘·/˘
Hapless wounded men were frozen.8/˘/˘··/˘
During day being struck down out of sight,9/˘·/·····
And help-cries drowned in roaring noise,8·····/˘·
They were left just where the skirmish shifted--10······/˘/˘
Left in dense underbrush now-drifted.9···/˘··/˘
Some, seeking to crawl in crippled plight,9·/˘···/˘·
So stiffened--perished.5·/˘/˘
Yet in spite3···
Of pangs for these, no heart is lost.8········
Hungry, and clothing stiff with frost,8/˘·/˘···
Our men declare a nearing sun8/·˘/·/˘·
Shall see the fall of Donelson.8·····/˘˘
And this they say, yet not disown8······˘/
The dark redoubts round Donelson,8··˘/·/˘˘
And ice-glazed corpses, each a stone--8···/˘···
A sacrifice to Donelson;8·/˘··/˘˘
They swear it, and swerve not, gazing on9······/˘·
A flag, deemed black, flying from Donelson.9····/˘·/˘
Some of the wounded in the wood8···/˘···
Were cared for by the foe last night,8········
Though he could do them little needed good,10·····/˘/˘·
Himself being all in shivering plight.8˘//··/˘·
The rebel is wrong, but human yet;9·˘/···/˘·
He’s got a heart, and thrusts a bayonet.10·······/˘·
He gives us battle with wondrous will--9···/˘·/˘·
The blufff’s a perverted Bunker Hill.9···˘/˘/˘·
The stillness stealing through the throng8·/˘/˘···
The silent thought and dismal fear revealed;10·/˘··/˘·˘/
They turned and went,4····
Musing on right and wrong6/˘····
And mysteries dimly sealed--8·/˘˘/˘·˘
Breasting the storm in daring discontent;9/˘···/˘˘/
The storm, whose black flag showed in heaven,9·······/˘
As if to say no quarter there was given10·····/˘··/
To wounded men in wood,6·/˘···
Or true hearts yearning for the good--8···/˘···
All fatherless seemed the human soul.8·/˘··/˘·
But next day brought a bitterer bowl--9·········
On the bulletin-board this stood;8··/˘˘···
Saturday morning at 3 A.M.8/··/˘···
A stir within the Fort betrayed8······˘/
That the rebels were getting under arms;10··˘/·/˘···
Some plot these early birds had laid.8···/˘···
But a lancing sleet cut him who stared9··/˘·····
Into the storm. After some vague alarms,10········˘/
Which left our lads unscared,8··/˘···˘
Out sallied the enemy at dim of dawn,10·/˘·/˘····
With cavalry and artillery, and went9·/˘·˘/˘··
In fury at our environment.9·/˘·/˘/˘˘
Under cover of shot and shell8··/˘····
Three columns of infantry rolled on,8·/˘·/˘··
Vomited out of Donelson--8/˘˘··/˘˘
Rolled down the slopes like rivers of hell,9·····/˘··
Surged at our line, and swelled and poured8··/·····
Like breaking surf. But unsubmerged8·/˘·····
Our men stood up, except where roared8/·······
The enemy through one gap. We urged8·/˘·····
Our all of manhood to the stress,8/··/····
But still showed shattered in our desperateness.11···/˘·//˘˘˘
Back set the tide,4····
But soon afresh rolled in;7··˘/·˘·
And so it swayed from side to side--8········
Far batteries joining in the din,8·/˘/˘···
Though sharing in another fray--8·/˘·˘/˘·
Till all became an Indian fight,8··˘/·/˘·
Intricate, dusky, stretching far away,9/˘/˘/˘·˘/
Yet not without spontaneous plan8····˘/˘·
However tangled showed the plight;8·/˘/˘···
Duels all over ’tween man and man,8/˘······
Duels on cliff-side, and down in ravine,10/˘······˘/
Duels at long range, and bone to bone;9/˘·······
Duels every where flitting and half unseen.11/˘/˘·/˘··˘/
Only by courage good as their own,9/˘·/˘····
And strength outlasting theirs,6··˘/˘·
Did our boys at last drive the rebels off.10·/·····/˘·
Yet they went not back to their distant lairs10·······/˘·
In strong-hold, but loud in scoff7·······
Maintained themselves on conquered ground--8˘/˘/·/˘·
Uplands; built works, or stalked around.8/˘······
Our right wing bore this onset. Noon8/····/··
Brought calm to Donelson.6···/˘˘
The reader ceased; the storm beat hard;8·/˘·····
’Twas day, but the office-gas was lit;9····/˘···
Nature retained her sulking-fit,8/˘˘/·/˘·
In her hand the shard.5·····
Flitting faces took the hue7/˘/˘···
Of that washed bulletin-board in view,8···/˘···
And seemed to bear the public grief8·····/˘·
As private, and uncertain of relief;10·/˘·˘/˘·˘/
Yea, many an earnest heart was won,8·/·/˘···
As broodingly he plodded on,8·····/˘·
To find in himself some bitter thing,9···˘/·/˘·
Some hardness in his lot as harrowing9·/˘····/˘
As Donelson.4·/˘˘
That night the board stood barren there,8·····/˘·
Oft eyes by wistful people passing,9···/˘/˘/˘
Who nothing saw but the rain-beads chasing10·/˘·····/˘
Each other down the wafered square,8·/˘··/˘·
As down some storm-beat grave-yard stone.8········
But next day showed--4····

The reader shows the same poem with its rhymes coloured and a stress row above each line, the notes beside their stanzas, and any word's definition on a tap; the analysis page takes the whole book apart. How every part of this site was made.

More by Herman Melville