‘So careful of the type?’ but no

Alfred Tennyson (1809–1892) · 1850

iambic tetrameter · ABBA · 28 lines · from In Memoriam A.H.H.

‘So careful of the type?’ but no.From scarped cliff and quarried stoneShe cries ‘a thousand types are gone:I care for nothing, all shall go.

Thou makest thine appeal to me:I bring to life, I bring to death:The spirit does but mean the breath:I know no more.’ And he, shall he,

Man, her last work, who seem’d so fair,Such splendid purpose in his eyes,Who roll’d the psalm to wintry skies,Who built him fanes of fruitless prayer,

Who trusted God was love indeedAnd love Creation’s final law--Tho’ Nature, red in tooth and clawWith ravine, shriek’d against his creed--

Who loved, who suffer’d countless ills,Who battled for the True, the Just,Be blown about the desert dust,Or seal’d within the iron hills?

No more? A monster then, a dream,A discord. Dragons of the prime,That tare each other in their slime,Were mellow music match’d with him.

O life as futile, then, as frail!O for thy voice to soothe and bless!What hope of answer, or redress?Behind the veil, behind the veil.

Words in this poem

quarried a.
Provided with prey.
shall v. i.
To owe; to be under obligation for. [OE. shal, schal, imp. sholde, scholde, AS. scal, sceal, I am obliged, imp. scolde, sceolde, inf. sculan; akin to OS. skulan, pres. skal, imp. skolda, D. zullen,]
wintry a.
Suitable to winter; resembling winter, or what belongs to winter; brumal; hyemal; cold; stormy; wintery. [AS. wintrig.]
fruitless a.
Lacking, or not bearing, fruit; barren; destitute of offspring; as, a fruitless tree or shrub; a fruitless marriage.
countless a.
Incapable of being counted; not ascertainable; innumerable.
futile a.
Talkative; loquacious; tattling. [L. futilis that easily pours out, that easily lets loose, vain, worthless, from the root of fundere to pour out: cf. F. futile. See Fuse, v. t.]
soothe v. t.
To assent to as true. Testament of Love. [Originally, to assent to as true; OE. so to verify, AS. ges to prove the truth of, to bear witness. See Sooth, a.]

Definitions and etymologies from Webster's Unabridged Dictionary, 1913.

About this text

‘So careful of the type?’ but no is in the public domain. This text is taken from In memoriam, Project Gutenberg ebook #70950; the transcription's header, footer and licence were removed and nothing else was changed. You may copy, print and reuse it freely.

Cite as: Alfred Tennyson, ‘So careful of the type?’ but no, in In Memoriam A.H.H. (1850), text of Project Gutenberg ebook #70950, Laurel, https://laurelpoetry.com/poem/tennyson-in-memoriam/section-55.html, id L18415.

Form and metre

‘So careful of the type?’ but no is 28 lines in 7 stanzas of 4 lines each. Every stanza rhymes ABBA. The metre is iambic tetrameter, measured from the stress the words themselves fix (confidence 94%). 100% of its stressed syllables fall where the metre puts the beat. The lines average 8.0 syllables. 11% of the lines run on without a stop at the line end.

See other poems in iambic tetrameter.

Measured by Laurel's pipeline, not copied from a handbook: how stress and metre are counted, how rhyme is lettered, how a drifted rhyme is found. Where the dictionary cannot confirm a rhyme the letter is withheld, not guessed.

Rhyme words, stanza by stanza

The word that ends each line, lettered by the rhyme it makes; a dash is a line whose rhyme the dictionary could not confirm.

  1. 1 ABBA noA · stoneB · goneB · goA
  2. 2 ABBA meA · deathB · breathB · heA
  3. 3 ABBA fairA · eyesB · skiesB · prayerA
  4. 4 ABBA indeedA · lawB · clawB · creedA
  5. 5 ABBA illsA · justB · dustB · hillsA
  6. 6 ABBA dreamA · primeB · slimeB · himA
  7. 7 ABBA frailA · blessB · redressB · veilA
Scansion, line by line

Each line with its syllable count and the stresses the words themselves fix: / stressed, ˘ unstressed, · a syllable the word leaves free and the metre decides. Read against iambic tetrameter. How this is done.

LineSyl.Stress
‘So careful of the type?’ but no.8·/˘·····
From scarped cliff and quarried stone8··˘··/˘·
She cries ‘a thousand types are gone:8···/˘···
I care for nothing, all shall go.8···/˘···
Thou makest thine appeal to me:8····˘/··
I bring to life, I bring to death:8········
The spirit does but mean the breath:8·/˘·····
I know no more.’ And he, shall he,8········
Man, her last work, who seem’d so fair,8········
Such splendid purpose in his eyes,8·/˘/˘···
Who roll’d the psalm to wintry skies,8·····/˘·
Who built him fanes of fruitless prayer,8·····/˘·
Who trusted God was love indeed8·/˘···˘/
And love Creation’s final law--8··˘/˘/˘·
Tho’ Nature, red in tooth and claw8·/˘·····
With ravine, shriek’d against his creed--8·˘/·····
Who loved, who suffer’d countless ills,8···/˘/˘·
Who battled for the True, the Just,8·/˘·····
Be blown about the desert dust,8·····/˘·
Or seal’d within the iron hills?8·····/˘·
No more? A monster then, a dream,8···/˘···
A discord. Dragons of the prime,8·/˘/˘···
That tare each other in their slime,8···/˘···
Were mellow music match’d with him.8·/˘/˘···
O life as futile, then, as frail!8···/˘···
O for thy voice to soothe and bless!8········
What hope of answer, or redress?8···/˘·˘/
Behind the veil, behind the veil.8········

On this poem

He said that Nature preserved each type; but no, some species are already extinct; and Nature says that she cares not for preserving anything, and so, in geological strata, we find the fossil remains of creatures that no longer exist. Why then may not man,

"Who seemed so fair, Such splendid purpose in his eyes,"

also perish, and have his dust blown about the desert,

"Or seal'd within the iron hills?"

If he be "no more"--if there be nothing beyond this life for him--then is man but a monster, a dream, a discord--"dragons of the prime," the Ichthyosauri that lived in the slime of chaos, were his betters!

"O life as futile, then, as frail! O for thy voice to soothe and bless! What hope of answer or redress? Behind the veil, behind the veil."
Notes from the edition 10

Section introductions from Alfred Gatty, <i>A Key to Lord Tennyson's “In Memoriam”</i>, 4th ed. (George Bell &amp; Sons, 1900; Project Gutenberg #36637). Line notes credited “[Tennyson]” are Tennyson's own notes; “[Hallam Tennyson]” marks a note that is wholly his son and editor's own explanatory bracket, not the poet's own words; “[Emily Tennyson]” marks the few notes signed by his wife. All three are from <i>The Works of Tennyson, Annotated by the Author</i>, ed. Hallam, Lord Tennyson, vol. 3 (Macmillan, 1908; Internet Archive worksoftennysona03tennuoft). Line notes credited “[Bradley]” are A. C. Bradley's, from <i>A Commentary on Tennyson's In Memoriam</i> (Macmillan, 1910; Internet Archive commentaryontenn00braduoft). All these number sections by the final, 131-section text, not the site's own 1850 numbering: from final XL to LVIII subtract one section number, from LX on subtract two, to reach the site's; the site prints the 129-section first edition of 1850 (see the work's own blurb), so two of the final text's numbered sections have no home here and are skipped.

  1. Stanza 1, line 1 See LV. 7. [Bradley]
  2. Stanza 1, line 2 Cliff and quarry are full of the fossils of extinct species. ' scarped ': cut away vertically so as to expose the

    strata. [Bradley]
  3. Stanza 2, line 3 ' spirit,' and all that it does and promises (10-18). [Bradley]
  4. Stanza 3, line 1 For the poet's own belief see cxvui. [Bradley]
  5. Stanza 3, line 3 'wintry' answers to 'fruitless' in 12. Cf. Liv. 16. The idea, as the next stanza shows, is that the apparent fruitless- ness of his praises and prayers did not shake his faith. [Bradley]
  6. Stanza 5, line 4 Like any other fossil. [Bradley]
  7. Stanza 6 Dragons of the prime. The geologic monsters of the early ages. [Tennyson]
  8. Stanza 6, line 1 'No more?' refers back to line 8, the idea of which must be taken to include the consequences drawn from it in stanzas 3-5.

    ' A monster,' etc. If all that we count highest in man ends in extinction, his nature is that of the monsters of fiction, or such an incongruous combination as occurs in a dream. The ' dragon ' of the first ages of the earth may seem horrible to us, but at least it was in harmony with itself. The point is not that man, if doomed to extinction, would be in discord with the rest of Nature, but that he would be in discord with himself. The conclusion here,

    also is not that such a self-contradictory being is impossible, but that man's life, if he were such, would be as futile as we know it to be frail. With the dragon cf. the * monstrous eft ' of Maud, I. iv.; with ' prime,' The Princess, II., of primitive man, 'Raw from the prime.' [Bradley]
  9. Stanza 7, line 3 ' answer ': cf. the conclusion of the Vision of Sin (Eve)- ' Redress ': for the injustice of this futile existence. Cf. Prologue 12. [Bradley]
  10. Stanza 7, line 4 The general meaning of this line is not doubtful, but it is impossible to say what metaphor was in the poet's mind. He may have thought of * the holy place within the veil, before the mercy-seat which is upon the ark,' Levit. xvi. 2, with which cf. Heb. vi. 19, 20. But it seems more probable that he refers to the inscription at Sais contain- ing the words, ' No one has lifted my veil ': for cf. in the section of Maud just quoted,

    For the drift of the Maker is dark, an I sis hid by the veil;

    and for the image of a veiled statue cf. ciii. 12. In De

    Profundis the words,

    our mortal veil And shatter'd phantom of that Infinite One,

    seem to describe the world of space and time. See also note on LIV. 15 for a quotation from The Two Voices. In any case the idea is that the 'veil' can never be removed in this life. [Bradley]

The reader shows the same poem with its rhymes coloured and a stress row above each line, the notes beside their stanzas, and any word's definition on a tap; the analysis page takes the whole book apart. How every part of this site was made.

More by Alfred Tennyson