Those Various Scalpels

Marianne Moore (1887–1972) · 1921

Free verse · 55 lines · from Poems

Thosevarious sounds consistently indistinct, like intermingledechoesstruck from thin glass successively at random—theinflection disguised: your hair, the tails of twofighting-cocks head to head in stone—like sculpturedscimitars re-peating the curve of your ears in reverse order: your eyes,flowers of ice

andsnow sown by tearing winds on the cordage of disabledships: your raised handan ambiguous signature: your cheeks, those rosettesof blood on the stone floors of French châteaux, withregard to which guides are so affirmative:your other hand

abundle of lances all alike, partly hid by emeralds fromPersiaand the fractional magnificence of Florentinegoldwork—a collection of half a dozen little objectsmade finewith enamel in gray, yellow, and dragonfly blue: a lemon, a

pearand three bunches of grapes, tied with silver: your dress, amagnificent squarecathedral of uniformand at the same time, diverse appearance—a species ofvertical vineyard rustling in the stormof conventional opinion. Are they weapons or scalpels?Whetted

tobrilliance by the hard majesty of that sophistication whichis su-perior to opportunity, these things are richinstruments with which to experiment but surgery isnot tentative: why dissect destiny with instrumentswhichare more highly specialized than the tissues of destinyitself?

lest by diminished vitality and abatedvigilance, I become food for crocodiles—for that quicksandof gluttony which is legion. It is there—close at hand—on either sideof me. You remember the Israelites who said in pride

and stoutness of heart: “The bricks are fallen down, we willbuild with hewn stone, the sycamores are cut down, we will change tocedars”? I am not ambitious to dress stones, to renewforts, nor to matchmy value in action, against their ability to catch

up with arrested prosperity. I am not likethem, indefatigable, but if you are a god you willnot discriminate against me. Yet—if you may fulfilnone but prayers dressedas gifts in return for your gifts—disregard the request.

Words in this poem

consistently adv.
In a consistent manner.
fractional a.
Of or pertaining to fractions or a fraction; constituting a fraction; as, fractional numbers.
magnificence n.
The act of doing what magnificent; the state or quality of being magnificent. Acts xix. 27. [F. magnificence, L. magnificentia. See Magnific.]
vineyard n.
An inclosure or yard for grapevines; a plantation of vines producing grapes. [For OE. winyard, AS. wingeard; influenced by E. vine. See Wine, and Yard an inclosure.]
sophistication n.
The act of sophisticating; adulteration; as, the sophistication of drugs. Boyle. [Cf. LL. sophisticatio, F. sophistication.]
tentative a.
Of or pertaining to a trial or trials; essaying; experimental. [L. tentare to try: cf. F. tentatif. See Tempt.]
dissect v. t.
To divide into separate parts; to cut in pieces; to separate and expose the parts of, as an animal or a plant, for examination and to show their structure and relations; to anatomize. [L. dissectus, p. p. of dissecare; dis- + secare to cut. See Section.]
gluttony n.
Excess in eating; extravagant indulgence of the appetite for food; voracity. [OE. glotonie, OF. glotonie, gloutonnie.]
stoutness n.
The state or quality of being stout.

Definitions and etymologies from Webster's Unabridged Dictionary, 1913.

About this text

Those Various Scalpels is in the public domain. This text is taken from Poems, Project Gutenberg ebook #62833; the transcription's header, footer and licence were removed and nothing else was changed. You may copy, print and reuse it freely.

Cite as: Marianne Moore, Those Various Scalpels, in Poems (1921), text of Project Gutenberg ebook #62833, Laurel, https://laurelpoetry.com/poem/moore-poems/those-various-scalpels.html, id L02622.

Form and metre

Those Various Scalpels is 55 lines in 8 stanzas. 80% of its stressed syllables fall where the metre puts the beat. The lines average 9.5 syllables. 12 lines end on an unstressed syllable, a feminine ending. 86% of the lines run on without a stop at the line end.

Measured by Laurel's pipeline, not copied from a handbook: how stress and metre are counted, how rhyme is lettered, how a drifted rhyme is found. Where the dictionary cannot confirm a rhyme the letter is withheld, not guessed.

Rhyme words, stanza by stanza

The word that ends each line, lettered by the rhyme it makes; a dash is a line whose rhyme the dictionary could not confirm.

  1. 1 A-AB--B-- thoseA · intermingled · echoesA · theB · two · sculptured · reB · eyes · ice
  2. 2 A-A---A andA · disabled · handA · rosettes · with · affirmative · handA
  3. 3 A-----A aA · from · persia · florentine · objects · fine · aA
  4. 4 A-AB-B-- pearA · a · squareA · uniformB · of · stormB · scalpels · whetted
  5. 5 ABAB--B-- toA · whichB · suA · richB · is · instruments · whichB · destiny · itself
  6. 6 ABBAA abatedA · quicksandB · handB · sideA · prideA
  7. 7 -AABB will · toA · renewA · matchB · catchB
  8. 8 ---AA like · will · fulfil · dressedA · requestA
Scansion, line by line

Each line with its syllable count and the stresses the words themselves fix: / stressed, ˘ unstressed, · a syllable the word leaves free and the metre decides. How this is done.

LineSyl.Stress
Those1·
various sounds consistently indistinct, like intermingled16/˘˘·˘/˘˘˘˘/··˘/˘
echoes2/˘
struck from thin glass successively at random—the12····˘/˘˘·/˘·
inflection disguised: your hair, the tails of two11˘/˘˘/······
fighting-cocks head to head in stone—like sculptured11/˘·······/˘
scimitars re-4····
peating the curve of your ears in reverse order: your eyes,14/˘······˘//˘··
flowers of ice4/˘··
and1·
snow sown by tearing winds on the cordage of disabled14···/˘···/˘·˘/˘
ships: your raised hand4····
an ambiguous signature: your cheeks, those rosettes13·˘/˘˘/˘˘···//
of blood on the stone floors of French châteaux, with11···········
regard to which guides are so affirmative:11˘/·····˘/˘˘
your other hand4·/˘·
a1·
bundle of lances all alike, partly hid by emeralds from15/˘·/˘·˘//˘··/˘·
Persia2/˘
and the fractional magnificence of Florentine13··/˘˘˘/˘˘·/˘·
goldwork—a collection of half a dozen little objects15···˘/˘···/˘/˘/˘
made fine2··
with enamel in gray, yellow, and dragonfly blue: a lemon, a17·˘/˘··/˘······/˘·
pear1·
and three bunches of grapes, tied with silver: your dress, a13··/˘····/˘···
magnificent square5˘/˘˘·
cathedral of uniform7˘/˘·/˘·
and at the same time, diverse appearance—a species of14·····˘/˘/˘·/˘·
vertical vineyard rustling in the storm10/˘˘/˘/˘···
of conventional opinion. Are they weapons or scalpels?15·˘/˘˘˘/˘··/˘·/˘
Whetted2/˘
to1·
brilliance by the hard majesty of that sophistication which16/˘···/˘˘··˘·˘/˘·
is su-2··
perior to opportunity, these things are rich12····˘/˘˘····
instruments with which to experiment but surgery is15/˘˘···˘/˘˘·/˘˘·
not tentative: why dissect destiny with instruments14·/˘˘·˘//˘˘·/˘˘
which1·
are more highly specialized than the tissues of destiny15··/˘/˘···/··/˘˘
itself?2˘/
lest by diminished vitality and abated13··˘/˘˘/˘˘·˘/˘
vigilance, I become food for crocodiles—for that quicksand15/˘˘·˘/··/˘···/·
of gluttony which is legion. It is there—close at hand—14·/˘˘··/˘······
on either side4·/˘·
of me. You remember the Israelites who said in pride14···˘/˘·/˘·····
and stoutness of heart: “The bricks are fallen down, we will13·/˘·····/˘···
build with hewn stone, the sycamores are cut down, we will change to15·····/˘········
cedars”? I am not ambitious to dress stones, to renew14/˘···˘/˘····˘/
forts, nor to match4····
my value in action, against their ability to catch15·/˘·/˘···˘/˘˘··
up with arrested prosperity. I am not like13··˘/˘˘/˘˘····
them, indefatigable, but if you are a god you will15··˘/˘˘˘········
not discriminate against me. Yet—if you may fulfil14·˘/˘··········
none but prayers dressed4····
as gifts in return for your gifts—disregard the request.14···˘/····˘/·˘/

The reader shows the same poem with its rhymes coloured and a stress row above each line, the notes beside their stanzas, and any word's definition on a tap; the analysis page takes the whole book apart. How every part of this site was made.

More by Marianne Moore